We show that doing so dramatically alters the conclusions. Dutch disease dynamics reconsidered crawford school of. The general nding in most of these papers is that there is an inverse long run relationship between the dutch disease. Dutch disease is a wo rding to expl a in a spe cific econo mi c devel o p men t whenev er a countr y wi t nesses a l arge inf l o w of fi na ncial re sources, o f t en r esul t i ng f ro m. Research seminars at the dallas fed are technical discussions targeted for phdlevel economists.
Assessment of quality of life of the children and parents. In particular, the resource movement e ect suggests that the growth e ects of. Studies from bjornland et al and schoppmeyer et al had the same conclusion 14,17. Dutch disease, resource movements, learning by doing, analytics of multidimensional dynamic systems, timevarying var model jel classification c32, e32, f41, q33 address for correspondence. Stevens shows the different aspects on dutch disease as they are laid out in corden and neary 1982, corden 1984, gylfason, herbertson, and zoega 1997, and torvik 2001. For example, bjornland and thorsrud 2014 disagree with traditional dutch. Kazakhstan the real currency and growth challenge for. My thanks go to willem buiter, otaviano canuto, jeff lewis, zeinab partow, and. Dutch disease dynamics reconsidered semantic scholar.
Dutch disease definition and meaning collins english. The narrow moving band, the dutch disease, and the competitive consequences of mrs. In the model, there is the nontraded good sector this includes services and two traded good sectors. The dutch disease is a resource reallocation process away from less pro. We can now cure dutch disease business the guardian. Stabilises the scal impulse over and above longer term smoothing by allowing deviations from the 4 percent rule to counteract large cyclical variations in economic activity or sharp swings in the value of the fund. The deindustrialization of a nations economy that occurs when the discovery of a natural resource raises the value of that nations currency, making manufactured goods less competitive with other nations, increasing imports and decreasing exports. Bjornland, clair brown, knut einar rosendahl, thorolav thoresen, and wei kang wong, ideas from ian mclean, and grants from the norwegian research. Similarly, roland 2005 argued that it is premature to conclude that the russian economy is experiencing dutch disease.
Unlike in the earlier 1 the figures quoted here mostly report changes between the fiscal years 200506 and 201011. The dutch disease argument suggests that in commodity exporting countries overvaluation of the currency due to increases in commodity prices harms manufacturing even though the economy as a whole may bene. Dutch disease dynamics reconsidered centre for applied. Our results suggest that traditional dutch disease models with a fixed capital stock and exogenous labor supply do not provide a convincing explanation for how petroleum wealth a. The core model the classic economic model describing dutch disease was developed by the economists w. This is fully consistent with the theories of dutch disease by van wijnbergen 1984a, krugman.
When the raw materials run out, the economy can be in a worse position than before. In contrast, dtcs detected with the ckicc in breast cancer patients are found to be of major prognostic significance. The dutch disease refers to the problems associated with a rapid increase in the production of raw materials like oil and gas causing a decline in other sectors of the economy. Commodity prices, total factor productivity, dutchdisease, sectoral growth. Pdf dutch disease and venezuelan economics in retrospective. The explanation for why some countries with natural resources see their economies weaken and jobs disappear. Dutch disease refers to the adverse effects through real exchange rate appreciation that such a boom can have on various export and importcompeting industries. We put forward a simple theory model that allows for such spillovers. We show that doing so dramatically alters the conclusions drawn from earlier models of learning by doing lbd and the dutch disease. Dutch disease, resource movements, learning by doing, oil prices. This is commonly the case in dutch disease literature for both oil fardmanesh 1991. The world economic forum is an independent international organization committed to improving the state of the world by engaging business, political, academic and other leaders of society to shape global, regional and industry agendas. The dutch disease is an old, wellknown, and still relevant paradox in economics. Dutch exports of goods and services, 196097 % of gdp source.
Lessons from norway by thorvaldur gylfason in the original sense of the term, the dutch disease refers to the fears of deindustrialization that gripped the netherlands as a result of the appreciation of the dutch guilder that followed the discovery of natural gas. Discussion of oecd deputy secretarygeneral ludger schuknecht. Bjornland 1998 and brunstad and dyrstad 1997 are recent norwegian contributions on the dutch disease topic. Escaping the natural resource curse and the dutch disease. But traditional studies of dutch disease do not account for productivity spillovers between the booming resource sector and other nonresource sectors. The canadian dollar, oil and canadas dutch disease. Dutch disease dynamics reconsidered, cama working papers 201955, centre for applied macroeconomic analysis, crawford school of public policy, the australian national university. Their results indicate that changes in oil prices have significant effects on movements in the real exchange rate, particularly, oil price increase leads to appreciation of the real. These diseases have mild and longterm consequences on the health.
Dutch disease is an economics term that refers to the negative consequences arising from large increases in the value of a countrys currency. Analysis of the dutch disease effect on the selected. Job losses in labour intensive industries such as steel, paper mills, metal refineries, textile manufactures have followed the removal of trade barriers at an early stage. The economic mechanisms behind the dutch disease have also been at work in norway. Seminars are open to academic researchers associated with local universities and research institutions. Cama workshop on commodities and the macroeconomy at australia national university and the camp workshop on commodity price dynamics and. Notes on trade in the presence of dynamic scale economies, journal of development economics, elsevier, vol. The key is learning by doing lbd in the oil service industries that spills over to the other industries. In the research literature, such a phenomenon is commonly been referred to as dutch disease, based on similar experiences in the netherlands in the 1960s.
T 0, sachs and warner 1995 and matsen and torvik 2005 that q u. Phd university of economics in bratislava, slovak republic abstract the dutch disease is a negative impact of the increase in foreign income on the economic development that often affects relatively small resourcerich countries. However, after this initial fall, at some point in time. Jul 16, 2015 the authors thank the editor, morten ravn, two anonymous referees, francesco ravazzolo, ragnar torvik, and benjamin wong, as well as seminar and conference participants at the reserve bank of new zealand, the iaae 2014 annual conference in london, the camp.
In this paper we describe the mediumrun macroeconomic effects and longrun development consequences of a financial dutch disease that may take place in a small developing country with abundant natural resources. In a first study of this kind, we take into account spillovers from oil to. A detailed analysis by westin 2004, based on data through 2003, concluded that, despite the existence of some dutch disease symptoms, russia had not contracted the fullblown disease by end2003. Academic visitors present current research in a 75minute seminar format on a variety of topics in economics and finance. Dutch disease financial definition of dutch disease.
Resource boom, commodity prices, dutch disease, learning by doing, twospeed economy, bayesian dynamic factor model bdfm this is a substantially revised version of camp working paper 620 with the slightly di erent title. The macroeconomics of a financial dutch disease abstract. Exchangerate economics for the resources sector sciencedirect. What is the e ect of an oil price decrease on the norwegian. Rajan and arvind subramanian december 2009 we examine the effects of aid on the growth of manufacturing, using a methodology that exploits the variation within countries and across manufacturing sectors, and corrects for. The dutch disease becomes serious if a large society such as the saudi or nigerian societies is afflicted, since the revenue from that wealth affects more productive and complex sectors, while it is less severe among the less affluent societies the dutch people for instance where things are less complex and thus the capabilities of. The authors thank the editor, morten ravn, two anonymous referees, francesco ravazzolo, ragnar torvik, and benjamin wong, as well as seminar and conference participants at the reserve bank of new zealand, the iaae 2014 annual conference in london, the camp. Oecd reports on netherlands, various issues 1 according to the handbook of development economics the dutch disease is defined as. In contrast to rtpcr, a positive icc did not predict worse overall and diseasefree survival. In particular, the study analyses the shortterm effects of the copper boom and the resulting exchange rate appreciation in zambia. The economic effects of north sea oil on the manufacturing.
For instance, if one is initially in a situation where all domestic resources are not fully employed before the energy boom, the boom may. Aid, dutch disease, and manufacturing growth forthcoming in the journal of development economics raghuram g. This paper analyzes the economic effects of the oil and gas sector energy booms on manufacturing output in two energy producing countries. We thank markus kirchner, rocio gondo, marco vega, and participants at the central bank of chile seminar and the bis cca research network on commodities for comments. The dutch disease theory ddt explains the dynamics of this dilemma for advanced countries such as the netherlands natural gas and the united kingdom oil and gas 4, 6. Dutch disease the phenomenon in which the manufacturing sector of a country declines when it begins to make significant profits from the exploitation of a natural resource. We then identify and quantify these spillovers using a. Clinical impact of different detection methods for. The negative effect comes about from a movement of resources out of the traded and non. The term originated in holland after the discovery of north sea gas. Traditional studies of the dutch disease do not typically account for productiv.
The government pension fund global gpfg and the fiscal rule together comprise a mechanism that delinks the earning and use of oil revenue, which helps insulate the fiscal budget from oil revenue fluctuations due to e. Norway, where the oil sector has been a main engine of growth for a few decades, has experienced something similar, see e. Other economists have tested this theory empirically, often on a national, onecountry level. According to the theory of dutch disease the core model, proposed by corden and neary 1982 and corden 1984, resource. Dutch disease dynamics reconsidered, working paper 20181, norges bank. As can be seen, after the new and higher oil price the relative productivities. Bjornland and others published dutch disease dynamics reconsidered find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate.
The traditional literature on the dutch disease typically predicts an inverse long run relationship between the exploitation of natural resources and the development in the traded sector i. Oil price, exhange rate and economic growth in russia. How to avoid the dutch disease world economic forum. The macroeconomics of a financial dutch disease pksg. Oil price, exhange rate and economic growth in russia 93 economic growth was researched by using techniques which allow structural breaks.
Russia is the largest exporter of natural gas and the second largest exporter of oil in the world, accounting for 68% of the countrys total exports in 2012. Their combined citations are counted only for the first article. Dutch disease uncountable an increase in the value derived from the natural. For example, ruehle and kulkarni 2011 study potential dutch disease. Wage costs have increased considerably relative to trading partners, partly due to higher nominal wage growth and partly due to an appreciation of the norwegian krone. Incorporated as a notforprofit foundation in 1971, and headquartered in geneva, switzerland, the forum is tied to no political, partisan or national interests. This gap is important as australia is sometimes assumed to be a case of a mining boominduced dutch disease.
Combine insights of varieties of capitalism literature with dutch disease. Dutch disease, natural resources, international capital flows, remittances, aid. An abundance of oil and gas can be a curse if not managed properly. Little is known about the impact on the quality of life qol of children and their families. The economic effects of north sea oil on the manufacturing sector. This thesis discusses the theoretical aspect of dutch disease in detail, but focuses. But when, as in this case, a disease bears the name of the first patient diagnosed with it, it would seem a bit harsh to require the patient to remain sick for the name t o stick. Chinese resource demand and the natural resource supplier. American economists have for years doled out advice to dutch diseasestricken nations, extolling the virtues of balanced economic growth, with the tacit assumption that the united states is advanced, diversified, and large enough to avoid the pitfalls of reliance on wealth from minerals. It describes how the initial good fortune of an exhaustible natural resource. The booming sector is usually the extraction of natural resources such as oil, natural gas, gold, copper. For some nations, natural resoures are a curse but it neednt be.
In this paper we develop the first model to incorporate the dynamic productivity consequences of both the spending effect and the resource movement effect of oil abundance. In this paper we develop the first model to incorporate the dynamic productivity consequences of both the spending e ect and the resource movement e ect of oil abundance. The development in therapeutic strategies has increased survival of children affected by inborn errors of metabolism with restricted diet iemrd. Cama workshop on commodities and the macroeconomy at australia national university and the camp workshop on. What determines the severity of the dutch disease in the rst place.
A further development of the theory of the dutch disease is provided in neary and van wijnbergen 1986. Resource shocks and human capital stocks brain drain or. Dutch disease in british english noun the deindustrialization of an economy as a result of the discovery of a natural resource, as that which occurred in the netherlands with the exploitation of north sea gas, which raised the value of the dutch currency, making its. The deindustrialization of a nations economy that occurs.
The traditional models of learning by doing and the dutch disease arise as special cases of these more general learning mechanisms. It is primarily associated with a natural resource. In particular, the author investigates whether there is evidence of a dutch disease, that is whether energy booms have had adverse effects on manufactures. Kutan and wyzan 2005 examine the vulnerability of kazakhstan to the dutch disease by estimating a real exchange rate equation that incorporates oil prices. In the new camp working paper 082018, phd candidate julia zhulanova and i revisit this question by analyzing if the transmission of oil price shocks on the u. Kazakhstan possesses extensive natural resources and relies heavily on revenues from the export of primary commodities, in particular petroleum and natural gas. Starting 1999 the kazakhstani economy was growing rapidly with average growth rate of nine percent annually with most of this. The views and conclusions presented in this paper are. The dynamics of relative productivities are shown in fig. In section 2 we present an overview of oil prices, exchange and economic growth in russia, followed in section 3 previous studies on this subject. In academic circles its called dutch disease, a term that was coined after the netherlands suffered a decline in. A diagnosis regarding whether a country is experiencing the dutch disease as a result of large oda inflows carries important policy implications and, hence, should be based on a careful. Norways catching up with and forging ahead of its neighbors growth studies show, counter to intuition, that the discovery of a natural resource may be a curse rather than a blessing since resourcerich countries grow slower than others. In the model, there is a nontradable sector which includes services and two tradable sectors.
We then identify and quantify these spillovers using a bayesian dynamic factor model. Applied time series for macroeconomics second edition. The empirical study found that the latecomers of lao peoples democratic republic and myanmar seemed to suffer from the dutch disease over the sample period for 19702015. The treatment of these factors in models of dutch disease may influence the severity of the predicted effects of a boom on the manufacturing sector. Dutch disease story, or at least the part that is described in these earlier articles as the spending effect. The macroeconomic consequences of scaling up oda terry mckinley abstract this working paper examines the validity of the claim that scaling up oda in developing countries will cause dutch. For example, if a country suddenly discovers oil and sells it on the international market, it may see a decline in the competitiveness of its manufacturing companies.
The canadian dollar, oil and canadas dutch disease michael babad. Traditional studies of the dutch disease do not account for productivity spillovers between the booming resource sector and other domestic sectors. Feb 22, 2018 an abundance of oil and gas can be a curse if not managed properly. Make sense of mixed empirical record of resource course. Be ine, bos and coulombe, 2012, vespignani 20 shows that australian monetary policy is ine. The fact that the dutch recovered fairly quickly from the disease that bears their name, while some other countries have suffered. The negative e ect comes about from a movement of resources out of the traded and non. There is a substantial theoretical literature on the dutch disease, see, for instancebruno and sachs1982,corden and neary1982,eastwood and venables1982,corden 1984,van wijnbergen1984 andneary and van wijnbergen1984. The classic economic model describing dutch disease was developed by the economists w. Instead, we find evidence of a twospeed economy, with nontradables growing at a much faster pace than tradables. The exchange rate, dutch disease and manufacturing in.
453 643 309 489 606 480 318 2 890 726 576 868 1571 1565 1162 778 577 724 1303 393 198 732 409 1675 649 940 1223 1265 1489 574 1405 699 1305 805 1273 1166 897 166